Musonius Rufus — III & IV: On the education of women

[image: bronze statuette of a girl reading (1st century), Wikipedia; this is essay #274 in the Figs in Winter series]

The third and fourth lectures by Musonius Rufus, the teacher of Epictetus, deal with the topic of how women should be educated. While, inevitably, Musonius makes some comments that would not pass muster with current ideas on gender issues, the Stoics in general, and Musonius in particular, were ahead of their time in this respect. It would, of course, be anachronistic to talk about ancient Stoic feminism. However, modern scholars have argued that feminism — understood simply as the notion that women are human beings like any other, and are therefore to be accorded the same dignity and rights of any other — is logically entailed by Stoic principles.

Lecture III, begins this way:

Exactly. The argument takes the form of a conditional imperative: IF x THEN y. IF women have the same inclination toward virtue, and capacity to acquire it, as men, THEN if follows that it would be unjust not to provide women with the same education as men. Notice, of course, that “gods” here is a reference to the pantheistic Stoic conception of divinity, i.e., nature. And nature — it was clear then and it has been amply confirmed scientifically since — has endowed people of all gender with the same basic mental faculties, despite the well known (and biologically necessary!) existence of some anatomical differences.

In lecture IV Musonius focuses more specifically on the education of children, stating:

Again, you would think that to be a no-brainer, and yet plenty of people seem to have a problem with such notion even in the allegedly enlightened times we currently live in. The faculty of understanding, or prohairesis, as Epictetus calls it, is fundamental to the practice of virtue, and needs therefore to be cultivated by men and women (and, we would add today, any other gender) in the same manner. Indeed, as Musonius puts it, who wants to have foolish human beings hanging around, men or women as they may be? Moreover, justice isn’t the only cardinal virtue that concerns Musonius, as he goes on to say:

So both men and women also need to exercise the virtue of temperance, as well as that of courage. Again, reason discerns no difference among genders for this sort of need. It again follows, then, that we should educate children in the same way, regardless of their gender:

Musonius acknowledges that men and women are built differently from a physical perspective, so that it may be appropriate for some tasks — say, those requiring strength — to be carried out by men. This is certainly not along modern lines of thinking. Then again, Musonius immediately questions even that apparently incontrovertible (to his contemporaries) assumption, by reminding us that there have been plenty of instances of women who have behaved valiantly in battle, having nothing to envy to men. He goes on to say that, conversely, some men are not strong, and may be better suited for tasks that are traditionally not considered “manly.” The picture that emerges, then, is not one of gender discrimination, but simply of letting people do what they are good at. Indeed:

What should we train our kids for? The answer might surprise the modern “helicopter” parent:

Musonius was alive in the first century of the modern era. Two millennia later, some progress has been made, and yet millions of people the world over still reject the basic truth of the equality of all genders when it comes to rights, including, but not limited to, that of a proper education. It’s a good example of the difference between knowledge and wisdom: we have known the basic facts for millennia, yet many of us still cannot muster the wisdom to accept those facts and act accordingly.

by Massimo Pigliucci. Stoicism, ethics, and philosophy of science. Complete index, by subject, at https://figsinwinter.blog/essays/

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store