Seneca to Lucilius: 47, on slaves and human beings

Image for post
Image for post
A Roman trireme carrying slaves, Are Pacis Museum, Rome, photo by the Author

“They are slaves.”

No, they are human beings.

“They are slaves.”

No, they are housemates.

“They are slaves.”

No, they are lowborn friends.

“They are slaves.”

Fellow slaves, rather, if you keep in mind that fortune has its way with you just as much as with them.

(Letters, XLVII.1)

Then again, the Stoics were famous for challenging common conceptions, and the founder of the school, Zeno of Citium, had declared slavery an evil in his Republic. Seneca here is not mounting a concerted attack on the institution itself, but rather focusing on what the fact that someone is a slave tells us about them. And his answer is: not much. What you call slaves, he says, are human beings like you, housemates, lowborn friends.

Moreover, he adds at the end of his list, they are fellow slaves as soon as we understand that slavery is not just a physical condition imposed upon others, it is — more fundamentally — a mental state that we impose on ourselves. He then elaborates, first on actual physical slavery:

“Reflect, if you will: that man whom you call your slave was born of the same seeds as you — enjoys the same sky — breathes, lives, dies, just as you do. It is possible that you will see him a free man, and equally possible that he will see you enslaved. … The fortunes of those you despise may come upon you at any time.” (Letters XLVII.10)

But in the ancient world slavery was something that could happen to anyone, as Seneca remarks at the end of the previous quote. Romans captured in battle would likely become slaves of foreign people, and the same happened to the many Athenians who fell prisoners after the disastrous expedition to Syracuse during the Peloponnesian War.

This, of course, doesn’t mean that slavery in the ancient world was somehow benign. But the concept was different, which explains Seneca’s forceful reminder of the fact that slaves are human beings like any other, and that being or not being a slave is a matter of happenstance, not under one’s control, and therefore should not be a reason for scorn.

“I will evaluate them not by their jobs but by their character.” (Letters, LXVII.15)

“Just as one would be foolish to consider buying a horse when one hasn’t inspected the animal itself but only its saddle and bridle, so it is extremely foolish to judge a human being by his clothing and his position in life. For position is only one more garment that surrounds us.” (Letters, LXVII.16)

“‘He is a slave.’ … Show me who isn’t! One person is a slave to lust, another to greed, a third to ambition — and all are slaves to hope; all are slaves to fear. … No servitude is more shameful than the kind we take on willingly.” (Letters, LXVII.17)

Stoicism, ethics, and philosophy of science. Complete index, by subject, at https://figsinwinter.blog/essays/

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store